Home Vegan Baking Spider Pie for Halloween – Texanerin Baking

Spider Pie for Halloween – Texanerin Baking

Spider Pie for Halloween – Texanerin Baking


This spider pie is a straightforward 3-layer no-bake pumpkin cheesecake adorned with a spiderweb, a spider mama and her 8 spider infants. It’s actually a lot simpler than it sounds! It will also be made historically or gluten-free.

I not too long ago posted these Spiderweb Brownies, and I posted these Spider Cupcakes again in 2016. Now I’ve lastly put the spiders and spiderweb collectively for this spider pie. 😀

And the pie itself is unbelievable. Must you not be concerned with spiders, simply skip all that enterprise and go to city in your no-bake pumpkin pie!

And it freezes nice, minus the ornament, so you’ll be able to already put together the pie and have it prepared when Halloween rolls round.


Right here’s an summary of every part you want.

Notice that the black cocoa powder is optionally available, however it’s what makes the spiderweb and the spider legs so black. Should you don’t use it, the legs will probably be brown like on my spider cupcakes proven under.

Black cocoa normally offers treats an Oreo taste, however not right here. It simply makes the chocolate style just a little darker. Should you don’t care in regards to the spiderweb being black, you’ll be able to positively skip the black cocoa.

For the eyeballs, I used the regular-sized ones for the mama spider, and for the infants, I used some which are 1/4″ or 6mm in diameter. The regular-sized ones match on the infants, as properly, so you’ll be able to definitely use them should you don’t have the small ones.

The crust

It’s a primary no-bake graham cracker crust. You should use store-bought graham crackers or make your personal do-it-yourself graham crackers.

Making do-it-yourself crackers after which smashing them to crumbs can be a bit time-consuming, however the choice is there do you have to not just like the components in store-bought graham crackers.

I don’t have time for that, so I take advantage of the grain-free Honey Cinnamon Seed & Nut Flour Candy Thins from Easy Mills (the photographer used common graham crackers within the pictures).

You’ll want a field and a half, and so they’re fairly costly, in order that isn’t precisely an ideal answer. However I had two bins about to run out (they’d gotten misplaced within the pantry), so it was the proper use for them. And the crust was superb.

So what you do for the crust is combine collectively all of the crust components and press into the pie pan. Then, you freeze it when you put together the filling.

Freezing every layer as you go makes it simpler to get fairly, clean-cut layers. Should you’re in a rush and don’t have time to freeze every layer, the layers nonetheless come out trying fairly first rate. Simply not fairly as good.

You probably have another no-bake pie crust that you just desire over a graham cracker crust, you need to use that. A gingersnap crust can be an excellent various!

You can additionally use a store-bought graham cracker crust for an excellent faster choice.

Cheesecake filling

I’m tremendous excited and pleased with this pie. All of the no-bake pumpkin cheesecakes I discovered use pudding combine or different processed stuff I attempt to keep away from.

Sure, the Oreos and graham crackers are processed, however I give do-it-yourself choices for these. The pretzels are, too. However nonetheless. I’m thrilled with the cheesecake filling!

The cheesecake portion of this pie comprises all the standard pumpkin cheesecake components however no eggs. Should you love tasting unbaked pumpkin cheesecake batter, you’re going to like this recipe.

I really like cheesecake batter a lot that I made a Purple White and Blue Cheesecake Salad, which is principally simply unbaked eggless cheesecake batter with fruit thrown in. 😄

The filling of this spider pie is (most likely clearly) firmer than unbaked batter however has the identical style.

And also you don’t must make separate vanilla and pumpkin cheesecake filling. You make the vanilla filling, take away 1/4 of it, and add the pumpkin puree and pumpkin pie spice to it.

Then you definitely unfold half of the vanilla filling over the frozen crust, adopted by the pumpkin layer, after which the remaining vanilla filling goes on high.

Methods to adorn it

As I all the time say, I’m not expert at adorning issues. So if I put up one thing with some ornament, it needs to be simple.

To make this spiderweb, you simply want a piping bag with a small spherical tip. Individuals say you’ll be able to snip the top off of a small Ziploc bag and pipe that manner, however I’ve by no means been profitable with that. I’ve simply ruined a bunch of luggage utilizing that technique.

I used Wilton tip #5, which has a diameter of 3mm. I additionally tried it with tip #2 (1.5mm) and located it a lot too skinny for my liking.

Should you use a smaller tip than I like to recommend and discover that the chocolate combination is popping out squiggly and tough to work with, then meaning the tip is simply too small.

I simply had a realization after hitting the publish button. As a substitute of creating a separate chocolate-based topping, you’ll be able to take away among the white cheesecake filling and add black cocoa powder. I did that simply immediately with a cake I labored on.

It is best to take away 1/4 cup of the white cheesecake filling to a small bowl and beat in 2 teaspoons (5 grams) of black cocoa powder. If it appears too stiff to pipe, which is probably going, stir in just a little milk.

It will, after all, make your white layers thinner. And should you use common cocoa powder as an alternative of black cocoa powder, your spiderweb will probably be a lot lighter brown than should you had simply used plain semi-sweet chocolate.

So I solely suggest this selection if in case you have black cocoa.

Oreo spiders

Should you don’t wish to use Oreos, you need to use my Mummy Cookies and skip the mum decorations. So comply with the recipe up till line 10. You’ll additionally must make the cookies a lot smaller.

You want one which’s in regards to the measurement of a daily Oreo (1.75″ / 4.4cm) and eight cookies which are the dimensions (1″of mini Oreos).

It’s the identical recipe as my Black Cookies minus the chocolate chips, nevertheless it’s necessary to press down the cookies after baking, which you don’t do within the black cookies.

Sweet eyeballs

You may make your personal sweet eyeballs should you don’t just like the components in store-bought sweet eyeballs.

This recipe for sweet eyeballs is my favourite. I’ve tried just a few!

The components are powdered sugar, cornstarch (or tapioca or arrowroot starch), vanilla, water and black cocoa. You is likely to be questioning why you’d purchase black cocoa powder only for sweet eyeballs, which might certainly be foolish.

However you need to use it on this Black Ice Cream or these Black Cookies. And the mum cookies I simply talked about.

It does take a while to make your personal eyeballs, however you need to use them in so many Halloween recipes.

Make upfront

You may make the pie with out the ornament immediately and freeze it. It’ll nonetheless be nice for Halloween!

You may put the eyes on the Oreo infants and utterly assemble the mama upfront. I wouldn’t do it various days upfront.

Should you put sweet eyes within the fridge, the moisture from the fridge causes the black pupils to bleed a bit.

So that you don’t wish to put them within the fridge.

Gluten-free choice

As I discussed above, I used grain-free “graham crackers” from Easy Mills. You may, after all, use any gluten-free graham crackers.

And you have to use gluten-free Oreos and pretzels, like Snyder’s of Hanover Licensed Gluten-free Mini Pretzels. For grain-free, Savor By Suzie sells mini grain-free pretzels.

Oreo makes their very own gluten-free Oreos, however any model of gluten-free chocolate sandwich cookies will do. All those I’ve come throughout are the identical measurement, in order that they’ll all work right here.

I hope you’ll get pleasure from this spider pie! I’d love so that you can depart a remark under should you attempt it out. Thanks!

Different Halloween recipes for youths

Spider Pie for Halloween
  • Prep Time:
  • Cook dinner Time:
  • Prepared in:
  • Yield: 8-12 slices

Should you’re gluten-free, see notes.



    Put together the crust:

  1. In a medium mixing bowl, stir collectively the graham cracker crumbs, brown sugar and salt till properly mixed.
  2. Stir within the butter till properly mixed.
  3. Press onto the underside and up the edges of an ungreased 9” pie pan. Pat it as evenly as you may get it. It’ll be thick! Freeze the crust when you put together the filling.
  4. Put together the filling:

  5. In a big mixing bowl with an electrical hand mixer beat the cream cheese, butter, powdered sugar, vanilla and salt till mild and fluffy.
  6. Take away 1/4 (197 grams) of the cheesecake filling to a different medium mixing bowl, and to that new bowl (with 197 grams of filling), beat within the pumpkin and pumpkin pie spice on low till mixed. Put aside.
  7. Unfold 1/2 (294 grams) of the white filling over the frozen pie crust (it’ll have frozen fairly shortly).
  8. Place within the freezer for about 20-Half-hour or till agency sufficient to simply unfold the pumpkin layer excessive.
  9. Then unfold the entire pumpkin filling over the first layer of cheesecake.
  10. Place within the freezer for about 20-40 minutes or till agency sufficient to simply unfold the second cheesecake layer excessive.
  11. Unfold the second half of the white filling over the pumpkin layer.
  12. Make the spiderweb:

  13. You may put the eyes on the Oreo infants and utterly assemble the mama upfront. Should you put sweet eyes within the fridge, the moisture from the fridge causes the black pupils to bleed a bit. So you do not wish to put them within the fridge.
  14. Soften the chocolate in a microwave-safe bowl at half energy in 30-second increments, stirring after each 30 seconds.
  15. Stir within the cocoa powder and coconut oil. The feel will change to one thing shiny and extra like fudge frosting. If it’s too runny proper now to pipe (it’ll rely on how sizzling your chocolate obtained), then let it sit a couple of minutes, or refrigerate and stir typically till thickened a bit.
  16. Match a piping bag with Wilton #5 and fill it with the frosting.
  17. It is best to make the spiderweb by piping on plus signal. Then make an X. Then you definitely join them to kind a spiderweb.
  18. Make the spiders:

  19. Reduce off the legs from mini pretzels with a really sharp paring knife.
  20. Use that knife to open the Oreo.
  21. Place the spider legs between the 2 wafers. Make certain the legs are pointing down like spiders and never sideways, like crabs. They received’t be in there very securely, however I had no points with shifting the spider onto the pie (nonetheless, I didn’t transport this pie!). If you would like, you’ll be able to pipe on some chocolate frosting to safe the legs onto the underside wafer. As soon as it hardens, it’ll act as glue. If you wish to do this, you need to scrape off the white from the Oreo. That might additionally make it extra spider-like!
  22. Pipe just a little frosting on the underside of two eyes for the mama spider after which connect them.
  23. Put the highest Oreo with the eyes over the underside Oreo piece with the legs. Place the mama spider in the course of the pie.
  24. For the infants, pipe just a little frosting on the underside of every of the 16 eyes after which connect them to the 8 mini Oreos.
  25. Place mama spider within the center and the 8 infants round her. Pipe on 4 small straight legs on either side of the spider child with a smaller tip like Wilton #2.
  26. Storage:

  27. You may freeze the undecorated pie for as much as 3 months. Defrost within the fridge for 1-2 hours or on the countertop for about 20-Half-hour.
  28. Once more, the sweet eyeballs shouldn’t be refrigerated. You may refrigerate the pie with the spiderweb for as much as 3 days, however do not add the spiders till serving.


  1. Should you stay outdoors of North America and have the form of cream cheese that is meant for toast (that is available in just a little plastic tub) fairly than American type brick cream cheese, then get two 300-gram packages of cream cheese, place it within the heart of a cheesecloth, and wring out the liquid till you’ve 450 grams of cream cheese left.
  2. You may want as much as 10 mini pretzels to be sure you get nice-looking legs, some pretzels may break whereas reducing – I used 5 or 6.
  • Should you’re gluten-free, make certain to make use of GF graham cracker crumbs, GF Oreos and GF pretzels.

Recipe by  | www.texanerin.com



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here